Shipping & Returns

Last Updated: Nov 19, 2018

All defined terms used below shall have the meanings set forth in our Terms and Conditions. See our TERMS AND CONDITIONS page.

Shipping Domestic

All our products are shipped via USPS or UPS depending on weight and size of packages. In the event that we are requested to ship to a PO Box, we’ll use USPS - as UPS does not accept shipments to any PO Boxes.

Local Shipping or Delivery

Please check local delivery ONLY if you are within the 11944, 11933, 11957 zip codes. We also offer Local Pickup if you want to come meet us at the Greenport Farmer’s Market: 414 First Street, Greenport, NY 11944. Please check those options when you are checking out on the site!

Shipping International

We regret that at this time, we do not accept any international orders. Please check back with us in the future as we may opt to update this policy.

Be a Greenie! Returns Your Empties to us.

Simply Nicki is always in eco-conscious mode! And we happily accept returns of your empty Simply Nicki Nut Butter glass jars for future use. If you’re in the area of Made Conscious Kitchen (8595 Cox Lane #5 Cutchogue NY 11935) or near our seasonal Greenport Farmers Market, please stop in and see us.
Thank you for recycling and helping to keep the world a little greener.

Order Cancellations

Orders that you submit online are processed immediately and may not be cancelled.


Unfortunately- Simply Nicki products are non-refundable and we do not accept returns of any kind.